--- title: How does the tribunal arrive at a decision? description: The review judge asks for information from both parties in the marriage under review. The information of witnesses and other documentary information is then gathered. Both parties can offer additional --- [Skip to content](https://info.aod.org/articles/how-does-the-tribunal-arrive-at-a-decision#main-content) English Show submenu for translations ![AOD\_Logo\_horizontal\_FullColor-medium-1.png\]](https://info.aod.org/hs-fs/hubfs/AOD_Logo_horizontal_FullColor-medium-1.png?height=40&name=AOD_Logo_horizontal_FullColor-medium-1.png) - [Default HubSpot Blog](https://detroitcatholicschools-7101042.hs-sites.com/blog) Open main navigation Close main navigation - [Default HubSpot Blog](https://detroitcatholicschools-7101042.hs-sites.com/blog) - English Show submenu for translations - AOD.ORG AOD.ORG Archdiocese of Detroit Knowledge Base - There are no suggestions because the search field is empty. 1. [Knowledge Base](https://info.aod.org/articles?hsLang=en) 2. [Marriage & Family](https://info.aod.org/articles/marriage-family?hsLang=en) 3. [Annulments](https://info.aod.org/articles/marriage-family?hsLang=en#annulments) # How does the tribunal arrive at a decision? The review judge asks for information from both parties in the marriage under review. The information of witnesses and other documentary information is then gathered. Both parties can offer additional information up until a point in time that is determined by the review judge. The procurator/advocate may then draw up a summary of their party's position on the matter at hand. In turn, the defender of the bond must draw up a similar statement in favor of the validity of the marriage. In certain cases the review judge may consult a psychological expert or other review judges to assist him in understanding the information. The review judge then studies the information and makes a decision. In summary, the final decision of the review judge is based on three criteria: the legal grounds as contained in the Code of Canon Law (i.e., ways of understanding the nullity); as understood by the judge(s) and the jurisprudence of the Vatican courts; in light of the information given to the tribunal (statements, declarations, depositions, documents, and reports submitted by the parties or professional counselors). Once the process begins, it does not stop unless the petitioner formally withdraws the application or neglects to follow through on a request of the review judge. A withdrawn or abated application is considered inactive, awaiting renewed interest by either of the parties or new information. - [Becoming Catholic](https://info.aod.org/articles/becoming-catholic?hsLang=en) - [Catholic Schools](https://info.aod.org/articles/catholic-schools?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Curriculum Frequently Asked Questions](https://info.aod.org/articles/catholic-schools?hsLang=en#curriculum-frequently-asked-questions) - [CSA](https://info.aod.org/articles/csa?hsLang=en#main-content) - [CSA](https://info.aod.org/articles/csa?hsLang=en#csa) - [CSA en Espanol](https://info.aod.org/articles/csa?hsLang=en#csa-en-espanol) - [Frequently Asked Questions](https://info.aod.org/articles/csa?hsLang=en#frequently-asked-questions) - [Cultural Ministries](https://info.aod.org/articles/cultural-ministries?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Black Catholic Ministry](https://info.aod.org/articles/cultural-ministries?hsLang=en#black-catholic-ministry) - [CYO](https://info.aod.org/articles/cyo?hsLang=en#main-content) - [CYO](https://info.aod.org/articles/cyo?hsLang=en#cyo) - [Development - Mission Advancement](https://info.aod.org/articles/development-mission-advancement?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Ways to Give](https://info.aod.org/articles/development-mission-advancement?hsLang=en#ways-to-give) - [Evangelization](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelization?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Formation Opportunities](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelization?hsLang=en#formation-opportunities) - [Catechesis](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelization?hsLang=en#catechesis) - [Lay Formation and Certification](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelization?hsLang=en#lay-formation-and-certification) - [RCIA](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelization?hsLang=en#rcia) - [Young Adults](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelization?hsLang=en#young-adults) - [Youth Ministry](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelization?hsLang=en#youth-ministry) - [Evangelical Charity](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelical-charity?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Walking With Moms in Need](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelical-charity?hsLang=en#walking-with-moms-in-need) - [Christian Service](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelical-charity?hsLang=en#christian-service) - [Grief and Loss](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelical-charity?hsLang=en#grief-and-loss) - [Pro-Life](https://info.aod.org/articles/evangelical-charity?hsLang=en#pro-life) - [Ecumenical and Interfaith Relations](https://info.aod.org/articles/ecumenical-and-interfaith-relations?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Ecumenical and Interfaith Relations](https://info.aod.org/articles/ecumenical-and-interfaith-relations?hsLang=en#ecumenical-and-interfaith-relations) - [Maps & Demographics](https://info.aod.org/articles/maps-demographics?hsLang=en) - [Marriage & Family](https://info.aod.org/articles/marriage-family?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Annulments](https://info.aod.org/articles/marriage-family?hsLang=en#annulments) - [Pornography](https://info.aod.org/articles/marriage-family?hsLang=en#pornography) - [Same Sex Attraction](https://info.aod.org/articles/marriage-family?hsLang=en#same-sex-attraction) - [Separation & Divorce](https://info.aod.org/articles/marriage-family?hsLang=en#separation-divorce) - [Natural Family Planning](https://info.aod.org/articles/natural-family-planning?hsLang=en) - [Parish Care and Sustainability](https://info.aod.org/articles/parish-care-and-sustainability?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Staff and Ministry Resources](https://info.aod.org/articles/parish-care-and-sustainability?hsLang=en#staff-and-ministry-resources) - [Technology](https://info.aod.org/articles/technology?hsLang=en#main-content) - [FAQs](https://info.aod.org/articles/technology?hsLang=en#faqs) - [Sacred Worship](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Mass](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#mass) - [Special Circumstances](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#special-circumstances) - [RCIA](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#rcia) - [Christian Funerals](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#christian-funerals) - [Lent Questions and Answers](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#lent-questions-and-answers) - [Liturgical Calendar Regulations](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#liturgical-calendar-regulations) - [Differences in Major Religions](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#differences-in-major-religions) - [Sacred Worship](https://info.aod.org/articles/sacred-worship?hsLang=en#sacred-worship) - [Sharing the Light](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#main-content) - [Mooney Real Estate Holding Company and Parish Incorporations](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#mooney-real-estate-holding-company-and-parish-incorporations) - [Parish Finances](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#parish-finances) - [Parishioner Data Management and Privacy](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#parishioner-data-management-and-privacy) - [Priests' Pension Plan](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#priests-pension-plan) - [Stewards for Tomorrow/Archdiocese of Detroit Endowment Foundation](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#stewards-for-tomorrow-archdiocese-of-detroit-endowment-foundation) - [St. John's Plymouth](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#st-johns-plymouth) - [Synod 16](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#synod-16) - [Unleash the Gospel](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#unleash-the-gospel) - [Compartiendo la Luz](https://info.aod.org/articles/sharing-the-light?hsLang=en#compartiendo-la-luz) - [Default HubSpot Blog](https://detroitcatholicschools-7101042.hs-sites.com/blog) [![Chill listening crop-3](https://info.aod.org/hs-fs/hubfs/AOD_Logo_horizontal_FullColor-medium-1.png?width=62&height=24&name=AOD_Logo_horizontal_FullColor-medium-1.png "Chill listening crop-3")](https://www.aod.org) Archdiocese of Detroit Resource Center Copyright © 2026, Archdiocese of Detroit